'Dawn of the Planet of the Apes' Plot Problems
Is a 10 year time jump vital for the story?
According to ComicBookMovie.com, the plot of ‘Dawn of the
Planet of Apes’ is described as such:
A growing nation of genetically
evolved apes led by Caesar is threatened by a band of human survivors of the
devastating virus unleashed a decade earlier. They reach a fragile peace, but
it proves short-lived, as both sides are brought to the brink of a war that
will determine who will emerge as Earth's dominant species.
After watching the trailer for the movie, I can truly say
that I’m extremely anxious to watch this movie. Tonally, this film is
definitely darker than its predecessor, a trend familiar for most Hollywood
sequels nowadays.
Essentially, a virus has almost eradicated the human species
off the face of this earth. The film is set 10 years after ‘Rise of the Planet
of Apes’, so the virus has done its work effectively, since whatever left of
human civilization shown in the trailer, appears to have set back people by a
century or two. And if Gary Oldman’s voice in the trailer is to be believed,
humans fighting amongst each other would have also aided this regressive
transition for the human race.
The last movie had Caesar and his fellow primates residing
in The Red Oak Forest, seeking sanctuary among its towering trees. To move from
that to a state of anarchy and lawlessness is a big, profound and perplexing
jump. It is a massive, if not revolutionary change to have humanity at the
mercy of primates. This brings the question as to whether this upcoming
installment should focus on the ten years that have passed, or whether it
should pick up after humans have been brought to their knees.
Of course, most would say that the spread of the virus via
airline routes as depicted by the final scene, should be sufficient to clarify
this situation. Had a movie been
developed on the 10 years since, it would simply be another ‘Contagion’ or
other virus movie.
But what the trailer illuminated was that humans were now at
the mercy of Caesar and the other primates. Isn’t it worth knowing how we got
there? The virus and the genetically enhanced primates should be part of the
answer but not the entire response. After all, Caesar didn’t possess an army of
millions at his command to have mankind under his foot. The trailer also
reveals that his hairy friends still reside among the trees, instead of
sheltering in apartments and hotel suites. Maybe this is a sign that there’s
much more to come from this franchise, and more left for the apes to do in
upcoming installments. This franchise is truly alive and well with the reboot,
and a ten year fast forward from the last installment may be crucial, to spare
the film from turning into another generic virus-spread movie.
In fact, a fast forward may be necessary as detailing the
path that led humans to that sorry state may be too ludicrous to put on screen.
Of course, I understand that the film is
dealing with intellectually superior apes, which in itself is an otherworldly
phenomenon, but having primates messing around with things like nuclear weapons
and such may be preposterous (just an example), for now at least given that the
previous film didn’t elaborate extensively on how smart these creatures are,
since it was merely an introduction.
While I would have loved to understand how things got so horrible
within 10 years in the ‘Planet of the Apes’ universe in lurid detail, it
ultimately may be unnecessary and distractive, as everything could be pinned
down to the spread of a virus that affects human beings, and not the apes. And besides,
Caesar and his friends don’t seem to have done much during that time since they
seem to have been holed up in a forest, rather than proceeding with executing
some megalomaniacal plan. That decade which was skipped may, as a result, be
ignored, as the most interesting and compelling story may still be waiting to
be told.